Does that prove that smoking is the culprit? There may be a myriad of other factors that contributed. Say for example the pollution in the air, the pollution in the water, the pollution in the food...I could go on...
And it could be evil spirits too.
Look, the link between COPD and smoking cigarettes is so beyond proven it's not worth the effort for me to even link you to anything.
HOWEVER...I have no idea why I didn't think of this before *slaps head* but while I was amazingly reactive to normal cigarettes in the past (now they merely stink like the dickens), I had a gardening client where one of the partners smoked, and I had no problem going into their house.
Why? Turns out the partner smoked organic cigarettes. They're just tobacco without all the toxic chemicals added to them. So if you really like smoking, you might do better with those on several counts. Just a thought.
And I'd guess no one's done any research on the effects of organic cigarettes and health, since most smokers don't use them. Too bad, really.
But I think it's not much of a stretch to believe that maybe smoking cigarettes that aren't laced with things like formaldehye and dioxins might be less damaging that then usual ones that are laced with such toxic stuff.
As for Gnomen's problems with cigarette smoke, that sounds VERY much like an allergy to smoke...like some people have an allergy to bread, eggs, milk, etc...does that mean bread, eggs and milk should be banned?
If it were an allergy to smoke then cigars and pipe tobacco would give me the same reactions. They didn't.
I already said part of it was a corn allergy. Oh, and several volatile chemicals like toluene and...things they lace conventional cigarettes with. You're not just smoking tobacco.
But by all means explain -- do I have to be a hermit because you happen to choose a habit that you can't practice in public without inflicting it on others?
Does your "right" to smoke your poisonous cigarettes trump my right to have a life at all?
Is that really your moral stance here or have I misunderstood you?
What you do in your own home is truly your business. I'm not part of the ban-smoking-everywhere crowd anyway. I'm far too much of a realist to take such a view.
Hey guys, I'm not advocating smoking...I'm just saying if we wish to victimise smokers and smoking, let's at least be absolute precise and accurate with our condemnations.
Actually I'm not advocating victimizing anyone. I don't see how that even helps anyway.
But I do think it's rather laughable for someone who harms me to claim that they're the victim if I merely suggest perhaps they should stop harming me, since smoking is hardly a necessity of life.
A parallel argument would be that people who drink should be able to drive when they're impaired because...they like drinking. The impact on others be damned, I guess?
Also what I'm saying is that quitting is an option for some, but not an option for the vast majority, and we have to find effective ways to cope for those who simply cannot (or should not - like my sister) quit
Actually quitting is an option for the vast majority. The problem is access to the means and programs to do so. Those who do have access (through insurance and businesses who help employess) have a much higher success rate than those who are pretty much on their own.
Despite knowing where my mother's smoking habit would lead her, because there's a large extended family and the pattern of who ends up with an oxygen tank and who doesn't is painfully obvious, I also realize that nicotine is more addictive than heroin (thank you Surg. Gen. Koop for that) and quitting is hardly an easy thing. I didn't toss blame at her all the years she was smoking, nor have I gone into "I told you so" mode now. What would be the point? Everyone gets to make choices and we all make some that are not so good. *shrug*
Also claiming "you just lack willpower" is somewhere between ridiculous, wrong, and downright unhelpful, so I don't do that.
However, denying well-done science is not an appropriate response, nor especially helpful, so don't expect me to play ball with you trying to pretend smoking is just peachy keen any more than I will join anyone in equally unscientific views such as the Universe was created in six 24-four hour periods or that there are multiple human "races."